Seasonal Pie of the Month Subscription

*Please Note: All Muddy's orders are for in-person pick up.  We do not deliver/ship product.

Choose from a 3-, 6-, or 12- month subscription of our scratch-made, all-butter crust pies. Perfect for a scrumptious gift, monthly family dinners, or pre-scheduled personal consumption. We'll feature our beloved classics (I'm looking at you, Shady Wake!) as well as ones specific to their season (hello, fresh fruit pies!).

Each month will be a happy flavor surprise, with the menu depending on fresh fruit availability, seasonal specials, and if we ever want to whip up something totally new & delicious. I mean, how much fun is a mystery pie? :-)

Subscriptions will start the month after purchase (or later if you want!) and will be for consecutive months with pick-ups* during the second week of the month on the day of your choice.

*Please Note: All Muddy's orders are for in person pick up.  We do not deliver/ship product.

One of our gnomies will follow up by phone to confirm the details of your subscription, including dates and recipient's info if planning to give as a gift! Please include best contact number at checkout.